Diskussion:Gérard Gertoux
In spite of my inability to speak Danish, for which I beg pardon in this context, I feel I should draw attention to the fact that this article has been inserted by a single editor into 18 different Wikipedias. Of these, 7 have decided to remove it:
His insertions remain in 11 Wikipedias:
The article claims that Gertoux is a Hebraist and a "tetragrammatist" and in support cites three sources that merely state that a book by Gertoux makes the claim on page 4 of the cover, without declaring support for the claim. The study that he presented as qualification for a doctoral degree was rejected by two institutes of higher learning because of its religious fundamentalism, as stated by Gertoux himself and a critic. The same fundamentalism is displayed in his publications: in his Noah and the Deluge: Chronological, Historical and Archaeological Evidence, p. 102, he states that "the appearance of man (and woman) from an apelike ancestor is scientific myth (propagated by Nazi doctors) [...] 5426 BCE. Creation of the first human couple: Adam and Eve, in Eden [...] 3170 BCE. After the Deluge the ark came to rest on the mountains of Ararat". Robert J. Wilkinson also commented on this characteristic of Gertoux's work.
The article counts as an achievement of Gertoux his membership of the International Association for Assyriology, which is open to anybody for €30 a year. Theodoxa (diskussion) 19. okt 2020, 16:26 (CEST)
Sletningsforslag: Gérard Gertoux
Biografien om Gérard Gertoux er blevet foreslået slettet på artiklens diskussionsside, hvor der argumenteres for sletning. Essensen er cross-wiki spam af en ikke-notabel person samt manglende relevans og oppustede meritter med tvivlsommme kilder. --Pugilist (diskussion) 19. okt 2020, 16:37 (CEST)
Slet - Som argumenteret på artiklens diskussionsside. --Pugilist (diskussion) 19. okt 2020, 16:37 (CEST)- Slet – kan ikke se notabilitet. Kilderne er bibliotekskataloger som medtager alt. Der er ingen personlig omtale. --Kartebolle (Dipsacus fullonum) (diskussion) 19. okt 2020, 17:46 (CEST)
- Slet – Enig i ovenstående. Økonom (diskussion) 19. okt 2020, 17:52 (CEST)
- Slet - Enig med jer andre. Vi bør følge de øvrige wiki'er, hvor den er slettet. Toxophilus (diskussion) 19. okt 2020, 21:01 (CEST)
Kommentar - Jeg har foretaget nogle nylige ændringer af referencerne. Jeg vidste ikke, hvad der var til diskussion. Indtil for nylig så jeg det.--Jairon Levid Abimael Caál Orozco (diskussion) 24. okt 2020, 19:19 (CEST)
Behold - Gertoux er bemærkelsesværdig, men internettet samler ikke al hans indflydelse. Det er ikke spam. Jeg har oprettet artikler på flere sprog (4Q120).--Jairon Levid Abimael Caál Orozco (diskussion) 26. okt 2020, 01:39 (CET)
 | Konklusion: Konsensus for sletning, fraset artikelopretter. Hermed effektueret. --Medic (diskussion) 27. okt 2020, 06:23 (CET) |