Newshoeson
Medlem siden 30. marts 2013
![]() | Hjerteligt velkommen til den danske Wikipedia, Newshoeson! (![]()
|
- Please remove the information about her royal claims on the English Wikipedia article on Emmelie too. It is irrelevant as you say. Thanks--BabbaQ (diskussion) 17. apr 2013, 01:15 (CEST)
Well this annoying user keeps putting it back on the site.. Is there anything to do about it? (Skrev Newshoeson (diskussion • bidrag) . Husk at signere dine indlæg.)
- Yes, recpect other people do not submit to you just because you are from English wiki and maybe have some supporters over there. --Trade (diskussion) 17. apr 2013, 18:29 (CEST)
- Trade, this has nothing to do with "respect" it has to do with accuracy and respect for the singer. She has never herself claimed for a fact to be of royalty she has said in one or two interviews that "she believes" she is of royal blood but it is media that has blown this our of proportion. And I will not even respond to any claims about "supporters" which is ridiculous and unfounded. Anyway the user has now added a more respectable edition of his earlier claims and I guess a small mention is more OK. --BabbaQ (diskussion) 20. apr 2013, 15:45 (CEST)
- Jeg kan se du har et problematisk forhold til sandheden. Forest introducerede sig selv i Melodi Grand Prix med at sige: "Mit fulde navn er Emmelie Charlotte Victoria de Forest. Og min tipoldemor var dronning Victoria af England."[1]. Det var hun selv der bragte temaet på bane, som det viktigste hun ville sige om sig selv. Det var hendes egen hjemmeside der havde "barefoot royal" som slogan og en klar og bastant påstand, om at hun var dronning Victorias tipoldebarn, der fik rigeligt med plads. Og det var hun selv, der talte om det i hvert eneste interview hun deltog i.[2] Dette er iøvrigt dansk Wikipedia, og her baserer vi os på hvad kilder siger, ikke de personlige meninger fra personer der nægter at skrive dansk på dansk Wikipedia. Vinson wese (diskussion) 21. apr 2013, 21:29 (CEST)
- You are hilarious. You wouldnt know the truth even if it hit you in the face im afraid. But I do find your latest version ok. But you need to learn notability guidelines. Your article on Marlene was not notable and badly made and deleted. --BabbaQ (diskussion) 22. apr 2013, 10:23 (CEST)
- Jeg kan se du har et problematisk forhold til sandheden. Forest introducerede sig selv i Melodi Grand Prix med at sige: "Mit fulde navn er Emmelie Charlotte Victoria de Forest. Og min tipoldemor var dronning Victoria af England."[1]. Det var hun selv der bragte temaet på bane, som det viktigste hun ville sige om sig selv. Det var hendes egen hjemmeside der havde "barefoot royal" som slogan og en klar og bastant påstand, om at hun var dronning Victorias tipoldebarn, der fik rigeligt med plads. Og det var hun selv, der talte om det i hvert eneste interview hun deltog i.[2] Dette er iøvrigt dansk Wikipedia, og her baserer vi os på hvad kilder siger, ikke de personlige meninger fra personer der nægter at skrive dansk på dansk Wikipedia. Vinson wese (diskussion) 21. apr 2013, 21:29 (CEST)
- Trade, this has nothing to do with "respect" it has to do with accuracy and respect for the singer. She has never herself claimed for a fact to be of royalty she has said in one or two interviews that "she believes" she is of royal blood but it is media that has blown this our of proportion. And I will not even respond to any claims about "supporters" which is ridiculous and unfounded. Anyway the user has now added a more respectable edition of his earlier claims and I guess a small mention is more OK. --BabbaQ (diskussion) 20. apr 2013, 15:45 (CEST)
- Yes, recpect other people do not submit to you just because you are from English wiki and maybe have some supporters over there. --Trade (diskussion) 17. apr 2013, 18:29 (CEST)